BlogHow to Guides

How Long You Can Keep Your Coffee Creamer Fresh and Flavorful

It won’t be wrong to say that coffee creamer is a delightful addition to the morning brews to kick start the day. The richness of cream completes a perfect cup of joe with its worth in gold. However, if your creamer has been sitting in the kitchen corner for a long, you must be curious to know how long you can keep your coffee creamer fresh, because, it really can easily go bad if not taken care of properly. 

This article will discuss the shelf life and the right ways to store coffee creamers, ensuring a delightful experience all the time. Also, we will take a look at when a creamer can smell and taste a little off. 

So, let’s dive into it.

Understand the Coffee Creamers


Coffee Creamer pouring in the coffee

There are two versions of coffee creamers, dairy and non-dairy. The product is designed to be added to coffee or tea as a substitute for milk products e.g., cream. You will see them in liquid, non-refrigerated liquid pods, or even powdered form. 

Also, various flavors such as chocolate, hazelnut, strawberry, etc enhance the taste of your coffee. Your personal taste and dietary preferences are the factors to choose the coffee creamer.

Is it Possible for Coffee Creamers to Go Bad?

Yes, coffee creamers can go bad easily, since a standard shelf life isn’t more than 6 months, also the type and brand of creamers play a role here. To make it more clear, the non-dairy creamers come with a longer shelf life than their counterpart,  the dairy-based ones. 

Talking about flavored-riched and sweetened creamers, they are likely to have a shorter shelf life as compared to plain creamers. The added ingredients contribute to their spoilage or make them bad. 

Also, the place where you keep creamers matters the most. To retain their freshness and flavor, you need to put them in a cool and dry place, without sun exposure. If the given environment isn’t creamers-friendly, the chances are they can spoil easily and more quickly. 

That being so, you should keep checking the best before-date, smell, and taste of coffee creamers to get the most out of them until the bottle gets empty. 

Also read: How to Make Cold Brew in French Press.

The Shelf Life of Different Coffee Creamers is Different

As, now you know the shelf life of coffee creamers varies and whether they are opened or unopened. 

Let’s know more about the duration of various varieties.

1. Liquid Dairy Creamers

Liquide Coffee Creamer

Dairy creamers have a shorter life span, because of their ingredients, which can go bad easily. According to a study, dairy-based products serve as an excellent growth medium for all microorganisms

To ensure the freshness and longevity of liquid dairy creamers, it is important to take into consideration some instructions for storing them. 

Unopened: The seal-packed coffee creamer typically has a longer shelf life of about 6 months in your pantry, provided you store it in a cool, dry place away from sunlight or heat sources.

Refrigeration after opening: The clock starts ticking once you open the liquid dairy creamer. You must store it in the refrigerator to keep it usable. Note that, dairy coffee creamers cannot sit at room temperature, so, always refrigerate them after use.  Additionally, after every use, make sure the lid or cap of the creamer is tightly sealed to avoid contamination. 

Expiry Date: Check the expiration date after opening and try to use it within that time frame. Because using expired coffee creamer can bring serious health issues. 

2. Non-Dairy Coffee Creamers

non dairy coffee creamer

When it comes to storage, there is a simple rule of thumb whether it’s dairy or non-dairy coffee creamers. “Keep them where you picked them up from the supermarket.” That means, if you picked the creamer from the refrigerated section, it should be promptly placed in the refrigerator upon purchase. 

On the other hand, if the creamer was lined up on the shelf near the coffee, it could be stored at room temperature until opened. These are shelf-safe coffee creamers. 

Unlike dairy coffee creamers, which are more perishable, non-dairy creamers have extended shelf life, allowing them to be stored at room temperature for approximately one to two months before opening. However, it’s important to keep them away from the heat sources, as elevated temperatures can cause spoilage even before opening them. Once, you break the seal, it’s recommended to shift non-dairy creamers to the refrigerator, where they will maintain their quality for about one to two weeks.

A side note: Always refer to the product label for specific storage guidelines. 

3. Powdered Coffee Creamer

Powdered Coffee Creamer

Powdered coffee creamers are cost-effective with the added benefit of an unexpectedly longer shelf life. There are two variants again, the dairy and non-dairy. 

Non-dairy powdered creamers can generally maintain their quality from 6 months to 2 years. (still, it depends on the brand and the ingredients used), as long as they are stored correctly.

To maintain the taste and freshness for a long, use airtight containers after use, and place them in cool, dry places. Also, avoid placing the creamer near stoves, ovens, or other heat-emitting appliances. Although non-dairy powdered creamers cannot go bad soon, they can potentially start losing the taste after 6 months. However, they are still safe to use, but you will notice the difference in taste. 

In contrast, dairy powdered coffee creamers hold the same storage requirements and life after opening, as you do with liquid dairy creamers. After opening them, place them in the refrigerator and use them before they get spoiled.

4. Non-Refrigerated Liquid Coffee Creamer Pods

Pod Coffee Creamers

Coffee creamer pods, aka creamer capsules, are single-serving and designed to be compatible with single-serve coffee makers, such as Keurig and Nespresso. These pods contain liquid or powdered creamer in multiple flavors. 

Generally, these pods last for about 6 months before opening it. But, once you open it, it is recommended to use it immediately. Otherwise, you can store the opened pod in the refrigerator for the next 3 days.   

The plus point is, that they are convenient for home and office use, reduce mess, and are hassle-free. 

Now, you know that all, but there is another type of coffee creamer, which is quite in demand and we call them “Plant-based Coffee Creamers.” Let’s take a closer look at them. 

5. Plant-Based Coffee Creamers

Plant-based coffee creamers are a nutritional powerhouse and dairy-free substitute. They are the ideal choice for those looking to cut back on dairy while enjoying a creamy coffee. While aligning to the dietary choices, these creamers cater to a broader consumer base. 

One might think that choosing a plant-based coffee creamer means sacrificing flavor profile, but it’s the opposite. You can find these creamers in various flavors from classic vanilla to mocha and seasonal variations like pumpkin spice. 

If we talk about the ingredients, they include almond milk, soy milk, and oat milk, each providing its unique taste and nutrition. 

The plus point is, that plant-based coffee creamers hold a longer shelf life. They can last for several weeks, or even months when unopened. 3 to 6 months is the ideal period. but after opening, they are good to use for up to 10 days and need a refrigerator.  

Read this if you are looking to buy a new coffee maker for your home

What are the Signs that tell your Coffee Creamers have Gone Bad?

You must be wondering or curious to know the signs that can tell that the coffee creamer has spoiled. Because you don’t want to take risks when it comes to health. 

However, coffee creamers don’t go bad immediately, even after passing the expiry date, but it’s recommended to use them as soon as possible. Also, be aware of these signs. 

1- Off Odor and Sour Taste: 

A spoiled creamer can lead to unpleasant flavors and loss of its freshness- also it affects the taste of coffee, entirely. 

You can easily access it as off smell is the most noticeable sign. If you encounter any such odor when opening the creamer, there’s a clear indicator that your creamer has gone bad. 

Additionally, the strange sour taste of the creamer is also a red flag to stop using it immediately.

2- Unusual Texture and Color Changes:

Fresh coffee creamers should have a smooth and creamy consistency. You may notice changes in texture, like clumping, or a slimy feel, when it spoils. This tells that the coffee creamer is no longer safe to use.

3- Expiration Date:

We already know that coffee creamers come with a short shelf life span after opening, however, you must be careful with the best-before date and the expiration date. 

The packaging already has the dates on it, so, if the creamer is sitting in your pantry for a long time, do check the expiration date. If it’s near to best-before date, you are good to go to use the creamer, but if the date has surpassed, it might be possible that the creamer won’t be able to offer its optimal taste and freshness. 

Editor’s Pick: Why is my Nespresso so Loud? Reasons and Easy Solutions

Some Tips for Extending the Shelf Life of Your Coffee Creamer

Here are a few worthy tips that can help you extend the shelf life of your creamer. These tips for each type are similar somehow. Let’s take a closer look at these pointers individually. 


First things first, storage is the most crucial factor that extends the shelf life of every type of creamer. Either they are dairy, non-dairy, or plant-based. Such coffee creamers are dry and cool places-friendly. You should always keep them where the sunlight and heat cannot reach them.

Especially, dairy creamers, are very vulnerable when it comes to spoilage due to the environment. A cupboard or pantry can be an ideal place for them. 

The Role of Temperature: 

To maintain the quality, taste, and freshness of coffee creamers, understanding the role of temperature is important. The ideal temperature for keeping them alive is below 50°F (10°C). 

Also, avoid keeping them in a refrigerator door, as the temperature fluctuations can cause condensation inside the container. 


Liquid dairy creamers cannot stay at room temperature after opening. The same goes for the non-dairy. Although, there are some shelf-stable creamers, that can remain at room temperature, still, you have to place them in the refrigerator once you open them to avoid degradation of the product. 

Avoid Contamination: 

Contamination can accelerate the spoilage of your creamer. That’s to say, always use a clean spoon to scoop out the desired amount. Also, avoid double-dipping or using a wet spoon, as moisture is the enemy, and can lead to bacterial growth. 

Ensure Sealing Tightly: 

If you don’t want to spoil your creamer, be vigilant to seal the lid or cap of the bottle tightly. Otherwise, air or moisture can ruin the creamer more quickly, especially, with powdered creamers. The container or jar should be airtight, so as to avoid contamination. 


Check For Expiry Date: 

Before getting your hands on the creamers, do check the expiry dates on the packaging. Also, take a glance at the “post-opening-expiry dates”. This is how, you can get the most out of your coffee creamers, because, now you know how long it can stay fresh. 

Good Quality Creamers: 

Investing in optimal quality creamers can be your best bet. They contain few additives and preservatives that enable creamers to last for longer compared to cheaper options. 

Can I Use Coffee Creamer if it has Surpassed the Best Before Date?

The health experts recommend not using coffee creamers after their expiry dates. But before getting into it, there’s a misconception to understand regarding the expiry date of food products

“Expiration dates on food products are not required by federal law, except for infant formula. When they’re used, they usually indicate that the food should have its best taste and texture up until that date. It is an assurance of quality, not an assurance of safety.1”

This means that, if the creamer has hit its expiry dates, it doesn’t actually mean that the creamer has spoiled entirely. However, you must use it within the next few days to avoid potential health risks. 

But, there are some side effects, if, unintentionally, you have consumed the spoiled creamer. Such as;

    1. Gastrointestinal Problems: In this situation, the common symptoms are nausea, diarrhea, vomiting, or stomach cramps. This is often due to the presence of harmful bacteria that have grown in spoiled creamer. 

    1. Foodborne Illness: Well, this happens in severe cases. You may experience food poisoning. Symptoms may include fever, dehydration, and muscle aches. 

    1. Abdominal Distress: This is also another side effect that can be faced if you consume the already spoiled creamer. 

Suggested Read: How to get rid of dizziness after drinking coffee

Wrapping Up

Coffee Creamers are undeniably the source of joy and a delightful coffee-sipping experience. By following the guidelines and precautionary tips, you can ensure that your coffee creamer remains fresh and flavorful. 

With that said, while making efforts to extend the shelf life, it’s equally essential to prioritize your safety and health. So, coffee lovers, keep your beloved coffee creamers fresh and tasty to keep the mornings fantastic. 

Ho long you can keep your coffee creamer fresh and flavorful

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *